Doubts About The Names and Numbers in Biblical Genealogies

Doubts About The Names and Numbers in Biblical Genealogies

Introduction

John Robbins believes there is divine “mathematical” significance in the “42” generations from Abraham to Jesus as listed in the 1st chapter of the 1st book of the New Testament, Matthew. But I question whether any worthwhile meaningful knowledge can be gained (or proven to others) by the mere search for numerical coincidences, especially since both the names and numbers in Matthewʼs genealogical list remain in historical doubt.

Doubts About the Names Listed in Biblical Genealogies (and/or the Numbers of People Listed in Them)

  • Doubt #1: “The Genealogies in Matthew and Luke
    (their differences, and attempts to reconcile them)

  • Doubt #2: “Did Moses Write the Lists of Genealogies in the Bible?
    (conflicting genealogies found elsewhere in the Bible)

  • Doubt #3: “Exagerrated Ages of the Sumerian/Babylonian Kings
    Compared with those of the Hebrew Patriarchs” by Edward T. Babinski

  • Doubt #4: Luke apparently constructed his genealogy around the idea that he was living in the very last generation, the “77th” generation since Adam!

    The 77 Generations

    by Jona Lendering

    In the Gospel of Luke 3.23-38, we can read the genealogy of Jesus of Nazareth. Like all genealogies in preliterate societies, it is not reliable: we may be confident that Jesusʼ father was a man named Joseph, but it is questionable whether his grandfather was indeed called Eli. (Matthew 1.16 calls him Jacob.) Going further back, the family tree becomes increasingly unreliable, although it is of course possible that the family of Jesus remembered correctly that it descended from David. The discovery of a first-century CE tomb of the ‘house of David’ in Jerusalem proves that descendants of the legendary king were recognized in Jesusʼ age.

    The genealogical truth was, of course, not Lukeʼs real aim. He wanted to show that Jesus was of Davidic descent and could therefore be the Messiah. Luke plays an interesting game in this genealogy, which we can appreciate by comparing his text with its sources.

    Luke started by combining existing genealogies.

    Genesis 5.3-32 (from Adam to Shem)

    Genesis 11.10-26 (from Shem to Abraham)

    Genesis 25.19-26, 35.23, 46.12 (from Abraham to Hezron)

    Ruth 4.18-22 (from Hezron to David)

    2 Samuel 5.14, Kings 1 and 2, Ezra 5.2 (from Nathan to Zerubbabel)

    Having combined these family trees, Luke inserted two names. In Genesis 11.12-13 Shelah is the son of Arphaxad; but Luke makes Shelah the grandson of Arphaxad by inserting Kainan. The other addition is Admin. In doing so, Abraham, who had belonged to the twentieth generation, moved to the twenty-first generation, and David moved from generation #33 to generation #35. In other words, Luke introduced a system in which every seventh generation, a special man arose: e.g., Enoch (7), Abraham (21), David (35).

    Finally, he added new names to bridge the gap between David and Jesusʼ father Joseph. Luke was more or less obliged to mention Zerubbabel, the son of Shealtiel, a descendant of David who played an important role in the development of messianology (more). Shealtiel was probably the son of one of the last kings of independent Judah and therefore a descendant of king Salomo (cf. Matthew 1.6), but Luke makes him a descendant of another son of David, the prophet Nathan.
    The names added by Luke are again highly significant: in the forty-second and the seventieth generation we find a Joseph, in the forty-ninth (7x7) a Jesus. Again, Luke plays with the number seven. Other interesting names are the four patriarchs in generation 42-45.

Luke Luke's Sources
77 Jesus of Nazareth
76 Joseph
75 Eli
74 Matthat
73 Levi
72 Melki
71 Jannai
70 Joseph
69 Mattathias
68 Amos
67 Nahum
66 Esli
65 Naggai
64 Maath
63 Mattathias
62 Semein
61 Josech
60 Joda
59 Joanan
58 Rhesa
57 Zerubbabel Zerubbabel 53
56 Shealtiel Shealtiel 52
55 Neri Mattaniah/Zedekiah 50
54 Melki Jehoiachin 51
53 Addi Eliakim/Jehoiakim 50
52 Kosam Jehoahaz 50
51 Elmadam Josiah 49
50 Er Amon 48
49 Jesus Manasseh 47
48 Eliezer Hezekiah 46
47 Jorim Ahaz 45
46 Matthat Jotham 44
45 Levi Azariah/Uzziah 43
44 Simeon Amaziah 42
43 Judah Joash 41
42 Joseph Ahaziah 40
41 Jonan Jehoram 39
40 Eliakim Jehosaphat 38
39 Melea Asa 37
38 Menna Abijah 36
37 Mattatha Rehoboam 35
36 Nathan Solomon 34
35 David David 33
34 Jesse Jesse 32
33 Obed Obed 31
32 Boaz Boaz 30
31 Salmon Salmon 29
30 Nahshon Nahshon 28
29 Amminadab Amminadab 27
28 Admin
27 Aram Aram 26
26 Hezron Hezron 25
25 Perez Perez 24
24 Judah Judah 23
23 Jacob Jacob 22
22 Isaac Isaac 21
21 Abraham Abraham 20
20 Terah Terah 19
19 Nahor Nahor 17
18 Serug Serug 17
17 Reu Reu 16
16 Peleg Peleg 15
15 Eber Eber 14
14 Shelah Shelah 13
13 Kainan
12 Arphaxad Arphaxad 12
11 Shem Shem 11
10 Noah Noah 10
9 Lamech Lamech 9
8 Methuselah Methuselah 8
7 Enoch Enoch 7
6 Jared Jared 6
5 Mahalalel Mahalalel 5
4 Kenan Kenan 4
3 Enosh Enosh 3
2 Seth Seth 2
1 Adam Adam 1
God God

One question is: why seventy-seven generations? The answer lies in the First book of Enoch, a collection of texts that share an interest in the patriarch Enoch, about whom it is written that ‘he was taken away’ instead of ‘he died’ (Genesis 5.24). This line caused many to think that Enoch had ascended to heaven and had written reports about it.

One of the five parts of 1 Enoch is the so-called ‘Book of the Watchers’, which was written in the third century BCE. It describes the fall of the angels and their punishment:

“And the Lord said to [the arch-angel] Raphael: ‘Bind [the rebel] Azazel hand and foot and throw him into the darkness!’

“And Raphael made a hole in the desert, which was in Dudael, and cast him there. On top of him, he threw rugged and sharp rocks. And he covered Azazelʼs face in order that he may not see light and […] may be sent into the fire on the great day of judgment. […]

“And to Michael the Lord said: ‘[…] Bind them for seventy generations underneath the rocks of the ground until the day of their judgment is concluded.’”
[1 Enoch 10.4-6, 11-12; tr. E. Isaac]

In other words, the day of judgment was to take place seventy generations after Enoch. Now this patriarch lived in the seventh generation, and we may therefore conclude that the author of the Book of the Watchers assumed that the end of history would be in the seventy-seventh generation.

In another part of the First book of Enoch, the so-called “Book of Similitudes” (first half first century BCE), we learn more about the last judgment. We read how the Messiah, who is said to be created before the universe and is called the “son of man”, will judge mankind, which has risen from the death.

Back to Luke. By making Jesus of Nazareth the seventy-seventh of the list, he is obviously playing with these thoughts. What he is in fact saying is that Jesus was the Messiah and that the last judgment is very, very near. After all, when Luke composed his gospel during the persecution by the emperor Domitian, there were only a few survivors of the generation of Jesus.

Comment using Google

Comment using Disqus

Comment using Facebook